In Featured Posts | June 2, 2025

Think about it – a fully loaded semi-truck can weigh up to 80,000 pounds. Bringing that much weight to a safe stop requires a complex and perfectly functioning braking system. When that system, or other critical components, fail, the truck becomes incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to control, leading to catastrophic collisions.

If a truck’s mechanical failure injured you or a loved one, it turns your world upside down, leaving you with medical bills, lost income, and a lot of uncertainty. You need clear answers and a path forward. Call Doubek, Pyfer & Storrar, PLLP at 406-442-7830 today. Our Montana truck accident lawyers can help you through this difficult time.

The Quiet Threat of Faulty Brakes

We see big trucks on Montana roads every day, carrying all sorts of goods. Their size alone means they need powerful brakes to stop safely. But sometimes, these critical systems don’t work like they should. When truck brakes fail, it’s not just a minor issue; it can mean a driver can’t slow down or stop thousands of pounds of metal and cargo.

Think about how much force is needed to stop a fully loaded semi-truck. If the brakes are worn out, not adjusted right, or have a problem with the air system that powers them, that truck becomes incredibly hard to control. This is especially true on Montana’s highways, where speeds can be high and the distances are vast.

Rules of the Road: Keeping Brakes in Check

Because properly working brakes are so important for truck safety, there are strict rules about how trucks must be maintained. Both Montana state laws and federal regulations set standards for truck brakes.

For instance, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) has detailed rules about brake systems. These rules cover everything from how the brakes are built to how they must be inspected and kept in good shape. These regulations, found in places like 49 CFR Part 393, Subpart C, explain the different types of brakes required, like service brakes, parking brakes, and emergency brakes, and how they must work. They also talk about things like brake tubing, hoses, and how worn the brake linings can be before they need replacing (see 49 CFR § 393.47).

Montana law also has requirements for brakes on commercial vehicles. For example, Montana Code Annotated § 61-9-304 states that vehicles generally need brakes on all wheels, with some exceptions for certain trailers.

Trucking companies and drivers are required to regularly inspect and maintain their brakes to meet these standards. When they don’t, and brake problems lead to a crash, they may not have followed the law.

Who is Responsible When Brakes Fail?

When a truck crash happens and bad brakes are the reason, figuring out who is at fault can feel complicated. It’s not always just the truck driver. Several parties could be responsible:

  • The Trucking Company: They have a duty to make sure their trucks are safe to be on the road. If they didn’t properly maintain the brakes, skipped inspections, or pushed drivers to drive trucks with known brake problems, they could be held responsible.
  • The Truck Driver: Drivers are required to check their brakes before heading out and during their trip. If a driver knew the brakes were bad and drove anyway, or if their actions (like “riding the brakes” on a long downhill) caused the failure, they might be at fault.
  • The Mechanic or Maintenance Company: If an outside company was hired to fix or maintain the brakes and did a poor job, they may be responsible.
  • The Truck or Parts Manufacturer: In rare cases, a defect in how the truck or its brake components were made could be the cause.

Montana uses a modified comparative fault rule in accident cases. This means that if you were partly at fault for the accident, the amount of money you could receive might be reduced by your percentage of fault. However, if you are found to be 51% or more at fault, you may not be able to recover any damages.

After You’re Home: What Comes Next

Once you are home after a truck accident, and the immediate crisis is over, you might feel overwhelmed. You might be dealing with injuries, a damaged vehicle, and a lot of questions about what happened and what you should do next.

One important step is to understand your rights and options. Montana has time limits for filing lawsuits after an accident. Generally, you have three years from the date of the crash to file a personal injury lawsuit. It takes time to investigate a truck accident, especially one that might involve complex issues like brake failure, so it’s helpful to start the process sooner rather than later.

Gathering information is also key. If you can, keep records of everything related to the accident – photos of the scene (if taken safely at the time), contact information for any witnesses, and all paperwork from the police and your insurance company.

Understanding if brake failure played a role often requires a detailed look into the truck’s maintenance history, inspection records, and the physical evidence from the crash scene. This kind of investigation can be complex and requires knowing what to look for and who to talk to.

Contact Our Montana Truck Accident Attorneys

A truck accident can leave you feeling lost and unsure of the future. But even in the toughest times, there are steps you can take to seek justice and fair treatment. Understanding the potential causes, like the silent threat of faulty brakes, is the first step.

If a truck crash has impacted you or a loved one, explore your options. Call Doubek, Pyfer & Storrar, PLLP today at 406.442.7830 or fill out our confidential contact form to discuss your case and explore your options.